Have you ever had a great group meal, but days and weeks later all you now talk about was the service? I admit that I have very different expectations on the level of service for a group (5 or more) as opposed to an intimate meal. When it comes to service in any situation I know what I want, and I’m prepared to relax in larger groups knowing it is harder.

We have a group of twelve and we are all prepared for a serious meal. Expense has been forethought and put in the background. We are celebrating the Melbourne Cup carnival and tradition has it that win, lose, or draw on Derby Day, we spend big on Sunday lunch.
Modern French
Maison Batard hasn’t made it easy on itself. The wrong group menus are on the table. Drinks are taking ages, especially for some, and they’ve split us into two tables of six that are close together, but still provide a separation of sorts. They’ve not been decisive in explaining the options, and I’m fascinated how they have lost a little patience with the questions that resulted from the confusion.
It settled through the meal. Really, nothing was going to dampen the great mood of our group, and it was as if service started to improve and get more light hearted once we asserted what we expect. Clearly it was not good enough to begin. It got better but there were still glaring mistakes. At one stage five plates that are part of a share menu were delivered immediately in front of the first table of six making it look like this was an individual dish, not a course for sharing. Our waitperson saw the mistake and corrected it in a nick of time, moving half the plates to the other table.



When he came back from his break during our main course he checked that it went fine and we got everything. The level of care had developed and his expertise ultimately helped our experience, but across the board it was not up to scratch. It was at this stage that Catherine and I discussed how this doesn’t happen at Trader House restaurants.
Like my previous time at Maison Batard, the food was excellent. Bright and fresh Merimbula oysters, as good as the Sapphire Coast locals can find; beautifully prepared chateaubriand with delicious sauces to accompany, and quality frites and leaves that you’d expect; and a chocolate mousse dessert that is a classic for good reason. In between squid made its mark, tuna tartare was scraped off the plate, and duck parfait shined, acting as dish that could own its own scene.



Starting with a drink upstairs was a highlight for many of the crew who arrived much earlier than the 1.15pm booking to take in the glorious weather. There is a buzz here that is palpable. Another highlight is the wine service, with our sommelier doing a great balancing act between the group dynamic of both wine lovers at any cost, and wine friends at a reasonable outlay.
There is no doubt in my mind that I’ll be back at Maison Batard in some guise. It is one of the hits on the dining scene in Melbourne since it opened. The question is would I suggest to others to go out of their way to try it for their next occasion? That walks the tightrope of “it depends”.
Enjoy this review?
Please subscribe to get new BLK's Food Blog reviews.