Oscar’s in the Valley – Swan Valley – Saturday 28 March 2026 – Lunch

Oscar's in the Valley

Winery / Modern Australian

The Swan Valley is a special place to me. As a much younger man there were regular trips to a part of Perth that is seriously under utilised and appreciated. There were some nicer wineries back then, and a generally approachable wine industry that had time to chat, and offer a generous tasting pour.

I haven’t been wine tasting here in years, but driving past places like Talijancich brings fond memories of discovery. The associated price differential to Margaret River was stark, and continues to be. A few weddings I’ve been to out here, for some of my closest friends, have been events that feel like I’m much further out of the city. There is simply nothing to not like about the Valley.

Lamonts was the first meal out here that I can vividly remember. I enjoyed olives for the first time. Diverse varieties and sizes marinated together, gently warmed in high quality olive oil. Life changing. Then there is Houghton’s. An afternoon here is a natural relaxant. Its flagship Jack Mann is a wine I love so much that it was the red for the bridal table at our wedding.

It’s been almost a year since I saw my Mum. Part of catching up is the drive and chat. The Swan Valley and the half an hour drive is perfect. All we need now is a comfortable restaurant to while the afternoon away. Oscar’s in the Valley hopefully will deliver.

Looking at the menu two things stand out. There are a lot of different dishes; they all sound delightful. Taking the balance of trying a few things but not leaving too much food behind, we settle on scallops and crab as our entrees, and the roast Berkshire pork for our main. What could go wrong with these tremendous proteins?

Absolutely nothing. Describing the crab as completely wonderful, I’m not sure how to describe the scallops except to say they are even better. The Blue Swimmer crab flesh has been removed, but kept in good sized chunks to allow the subtle flavour to penetrate through the dish, the grape standing out as a nice ingredient to combine with. Continuing a recent love affair with corn, the Abrolhos Island scallops combine beautifully too, but the depth of flavour partly from the caramelisation, is extraordinary.

I’m enjoying a glass of John Kosovich Chenin Blanc with this immaculate food, and scraping the plate with house sourdough. Kosovich is one of my favourite producers in the Valley, so keeping on the theme I also choose their Malbec Petit Verdot next. Generously poured, I love the softness of this red. Next to the Beverley Berkshire Pork, also very generously served, it works well.

Beverley is a place my close friend from uni comes from, and I’m now close to his entire family. I played footy for Beverley in the couple of years leading up to moving to Melbourne, and the whole community is fantastic. Having just seen my friend and his family the day prior, I was glad Mum put in her vote for the delicious pork. Sides of dry aged roasted potatoes, and charred broccolini, felt like the perfect accompaniments, and they were both excellent in themselves, but even better with the pork.

Mum doesn’t always go for dessert, but Oscar’s had her curious for a try of the Eton Mess, and I was happy to share with dinner plans in the evening at Lulu keeping me sensible. I’ve always like the combination of crunch from the meringue and the cream in a mess, but here the lift comes from fresh fig and fig leaf, cutting through the dish superbly.

From the start, service had been knowledgeable in a way we didn’t expect. You could tell from the busy restaurant but calm floorstaff that they had their roles down pat, and we were impressed with those serving us today.

Just like several experiences in this area, Oscar’s left a lasting impression on me, and I have a feeling it will not be forgotten. Future visits seem inevitable, with great food and service, reasonable prices across the board including wine, and an area that is as conducive to a date as it is to a family get together.

The Parlour @ Gerald’s Bar – Carlton North – Saturday 21 March 2026 – Dinner

The Parlour @ Gerald's Bar

Modern Australian / Local

920 Lygon Street Carlton North
Mon to Thurs from 5pm Plus lunch Fri to Sun
(03) 9349 4748

Versatility is a skill that restaurants and bars often yearn for but never attain. Cross-over vibrancy that moves through a venue, and covers multiple periods of the day and night. The majority of hotels try and fail. To have a space designed for multiple purposes. A space that moves effortlessly through lunch to dinner, or from casual to smart.

When this equation is solved it leads to success. Success is profitable. Profit allows for long-time well looked after staff. The flywheel spins. For Gerald’s Bar this level of success meant it outgrew its Rathdowne Street digs, and took the ultimate risk to go bigger. Going bigger involves a fine dining aspect.

The Parlour at Gerald’s Bar is in its infancy. With an early booking we thought the clientele would build. Slightly tucked away from the main sprawling bar, but within an atmospheric earshot, our expert team of waitstaff explained the tasting menu.

Having started with a superbly made house martini (olive oil), and the ‘Dolores’, our snacks arrived with some fanfare from the floorstaff. They were not wrong. The taste of the fish and chips bite transports you to your classic fish and chippery, without the newspaper. With specially imported aged raw milk cheddar scattered on top, the tart is almost as good.

Sourdough is special. Making it a course on tasting menus around the country is possibly controversial, but in this case (and many others) it deserves some stardom. Paired with spectacular warmed honey encased in butter, you can understand why this shouldn’t always be considered a side. 

Bringing back memories of a terrific recent wedding at Provenance, the Henty Chardonnay shows its careful handling in the vineyard, paying dividends for Catherine. My Wildeberg Chenin Blanc from South Africa is beautifully chosen by the bar, leaving me without any doubt I can put my trust in the sommelier.

A collection of end of season black star tomatoes prepared several ways, with flamed cockles underneath, shows ingenuity in the kitchen. Tomato as a star is not new on tasting menus, and it is one of those ingredients that can really shine. I welcome the style of this dish that is combined and lifted by a tomato broth with vanilla.

Our highlight dish is the nannygai. A member of the snapper family, I am enamoured with the clever presentation. The various elements come together in gorgeous harmony. Like our wedding though, the beauty of the main ingredient should be presented without being dulled by the risoni, even though the teaming of the two (and the courgette and basil) were a match made in heaven. Adding even a further notch was the Meyer-Fonne Riesling from Alsace, backing up the initial superb pick.

Preparing for main I turned to a red in the form of the 2015 Urbina Tempranillo from Rioja. This was paired with the enormous main of Wild Shot fallow deer loin, which included a rich terrine like ball (caillette), and charred and pureed sweetcorn and juniper. The richness of the dish eventually stopped Catherine continuing, but I just couldn’t stop, especially with the corn which elevated the dish considerably, and the aged red too.

Presenting the cheese trolley like a skilled salesperson, the incredibly well chosen and diverse range of cheeses had us captivated. Due to our generally limited appetite at the end of the savoury courses, we ordinarily would wave off any mention of cheese prior to dessert but we were sold. By the time we had a tiny slither (but with a generous and delicious range of accompaniments) we were up to pussy’s bow.

Entirely satisfied, nothing stops Catherine and I having dessert, and we prepared ourselves for the lemon verbena mousse, presented with a delicately sliced peach topping, and raspberry sorbet. Like the other dishes there is some inventiveness here, clever combinations of ingredients without going overboard, and a less-is-more thought process with the ability to match the flavour profile with some great wine choices.

Add immaculate service to the stunning food and wine, and you have what should become a popular offering. Tonight was quiet in The Parlour with only two tables on a Saturday evening, but if the word gets out expect this new aspect of Gerald’s Bar to be just as popular as the rest of the venue.