Too hot to handle at Maison Batard?

Too hot to handle at Maison Batard?

Have you ever had a great group meal, but days and weeks later all you now talk about was the service? I admit that I have very different expectations on the level of service for a group (5 or more) as opposed to an intimate meal. When it comes to service in any situation I know what I want, and I’m prepared to relax in larger groups knowing it is harder.

We have a group of twelve and we are all prepared for a serious meal. Expense has been forethought and put in the background. We are celebrating the Melbourne Cup carnival and tradition has it that win, lose, or draw on Derby Day, we spend big on Sunday lunch.

Maison Batard

Modern French

Maison Batard hasn’t made it easy on itself. The wrong group menus are on the table. Drinks are taking ages, especially for some, and they’ve split us into two tables of six that are close together, but still provide a separation of sorts. They’ve not been decisive in explaining the options, and I’m fascinated how they have lost a little patience with the questions that resulted from the confusion.

It settled through the meal. Really, nothing was going to dampen the great mood of our group, and it was as if service started to improve and get more light hearted once we asserted what we expect. Clearly it was not good enough to begin. It got better but there were still glaring mistakes. At one stage five plates that are part of a share menu were delivered immediately in front of the first table of six making it look like this was an individual dish, not a course for sharing. Our waitperson saw the mistake and corrected it in a nick of time, moving half the plates to the other table.

When he came back from his break during our main course he checked that it went fine and we got everything. The level of care had developed and his expertise ultimately helped our experience, but across the board it was not up to scratch. It was at this stage that Catherine and I discussed how this doesn’t happen at Trader House restaurants.

Like my previous time at Maison Batard, the food was excellent. Bright and fresh Merimbula oysters, as good as the Sapphire Coast locals can find; beautifully prepared chateaubriand with delicious sauces to accompany, and quality frites and leaves that you’d expect; and a chocolate mousse dessert that is a classic for good reason. In between squid made its mark, tuna tartare was scraped off the plate, and duck parfait shined, acting as dish that could own its own scene.

Starting with a drink upstairs was a highlight for many of the crew who arrived much earlier than the 1.15pm booking to take in the glorious weather. There is a buzz here that is palpable. Another highlight is the wine service, with our sommelier doing a great balancing act between the group dynamic of both wine lovers at any cost, and wine friends at a reasonable outlay.

There is no doubt in my mind that I’ll be back at Maison Batard in some guise. It is one of the hits on the dining scene in Melbourne since it opened. The question is would I suggest to others to go out of their way to try it for their next occasion? That walks the tightrope of “it depends”.

Outside the CBD – 8 brilliant Melbourne restaurants

Outside the CBD – 8 brilliant Melbourne restaurants

BLK’s Food Blog favourites – October 2026 edition

Stokehouse is one of the best Melbourne restaurants

A few months ago I wrote about my favourite Melbourne restaurants in the CBD, and I expanded that list to include my favourites outside of the CBD too. This is my list of the Best Melbourne Restaurants that are outside of the CBD.

If you get around to all of these over time you’ll get a taste of the bounty Melbourne has to offer diners. Most take some planning to book, but there are a few that you can comfortably walk-in to outside of busy hours.

There’s no actual order below – I’ve just written about the places that I love as I’ve thought of them.

Best Melbourne restaurants outside of the CBD

O.MY – epitome of farm to table

There are many things I love about O.MY. The service staff led by Chayse Bertoncello, and the kitchen led by his brother Blayne are the two main ones though.

O.MY has evolved. From the beginning the script was written. The vision was pursued vigorously, and even a heartbreaking fire couldn’t stop the Bertoncello tornado from making waves.

We’ve been back recently with friends. There are dishes and wine choices that make you grin the broadest grin. It’s a special place.

O.MY

Modern Australian / Farm-to-table

70 Princes Hwy Beaconsfield VIC 3807
Wed–Fri Dinner 6pm; Sat–Sun Lunch 12pm & Dinner 6pm; Mon–Tue Closed
+61 3 9769 9000

Napier Quarter – most outstanding local wine bar

How can a neighbourhood wine bar get under my skin like Napier Quarter? This place just doesn’t miss. These days I take some expectations, but part of the charm is the quaintness, as if it has been mastered.

The wines are superbly chosen and reasonably priced. The food always screams freshness and vibrancy. The service is as polished as a wine bar in Fitzroy gets.

Napier Quarter

Wine Bar / Modern Australian

Monday — Friday 8am – late Saturday 9am – late Sunday 12 noon – 6pm
03 9416 0666

Stokehouse – the jewel on Port Phillip

Big time. It doesn’t get more big time than Stokehouse. This St Kilda icon has also survived fire, and has risen from the ashes with even more strength and meaning. Catherine and I utterly love our time here.

It’s expensive but it is always worth it. I find it to be the most delightful place to dine at with a view in Melbourne. Unlike other tourist spots, it backs it up with immaculate food and wine.

Stokehouse

Seafood / Modern Australian

Attica – reinventing modern Australian

Yes it has gotten to the height of exclusiveness with the cost of the tasting menu, but it is still cheaper than three Michelin Stars in Paris or New York.

From incredible and modern; to native and experimental; to iconic and assured; Attica has had a journey for the ages. I wasn’t around to say I was dining there at the start, but I’ve seen every act since, and they are all show stoppers.

Attica

Modern Australian / Fine Dining

Etta – unassuming Brunswick icon

On the way home I raved about Etta so many times Catherine told me to shut it. I was enthrauled and I guess I just couldn’t stop going on.

There are a range of dishes that I would struggle to not repeat at Etta. Add to that the Brunswick vibe and you have a place that is magnetic.

Etta

Modern Australian / Fine Dining

Tuesday to Friday, 5pm-late Saturday 12pm-late
(03) 9448 8233

Cutler & Co. – the Grandfather of Gimlet

If you want a caring big night out experience, Cutler & Co. will deliver on every front. I’ve accumulated many meals here over the years and the fabric that binds is the collective experience.

It’s a place I haven’t yet dined alone, but besides that I’ve been with Catherine, in small groups, and large groups. At one time even the now Marion was part of Cutler as a function space.

This is the place that gave Gimlet its rocket launcher, and perhaps would be even more popular if Gimlet was never born.

Cutler & Co.

Modern Australian / Fine Dining

Dinner Wednesday to Sunday Lunch Sunday
(03) 9419 4888

Minamishima – sushi that stuns

The essence of extraordinary Japanese food comes down to preciseness, quality, and mastery. In a backstreet of Richmond, this is all on show. The treatment of nigiri sushi course after course is stunning.

Putting aside the expense, being at Minamishima is as close to a sushi joint on the border of the Tokyo Fish Market that you can have. Now it has over ten years on the board and nothing needs to change.

Minamishima

Japanese / Omakase Sushi

Tue–Sat from 6pm (two sittings: 6pm & 8:30pm); bookings open 1st of each month at 12pm by phone
(03) 9429 5180

Yiaga – the new kid on the Fitzroy Gardens block

Our experience at Yiaga was magnificent. Hugh Allen’s purposeful, architecturally pleasing restaurant showed the incredible learnings he has had over years at Vue Du Monde and Noma.

The degustation only menu is expensive, but wonderful. Service is sharp, showing a very high quality of training, and professional ease. One of the hardest and hottest tables to book since it opened in October 2025, its a matter of forward planning or luck that will get you in.

Yiaga

Modern Australian

Dinner Wed to Sat Lunch Fri and Sat
+61396913800

Best Restaurants in Melbourne CBD – 8 of my favourites

Best Italian Restaurants in Melbourne – 8 of my favourites

Best Restaurants in Melbourne – 16 of my favourites